Good morning. Before you start casting stones at Virginia, where snow this week stranded motorists on a highway outside Washington, D.C., take a short trip down memory lane. Pennsylvania made similar headlines in 2016 and again in 2018, though the crisis was leavened the second time around by a wandering camel.
Forward BizNewsPA Forward BizNewsPA

Lawsuit challenges revised PA building standards

State regulators violated the Pennsylvania constitution when they updated standards that ensure buildings are accessible to people with disabilities, claims a lawsuit filed last week by a trade group for residential builders.
  • The Pennsylvania Builders Association doesn’t oppose standards for accessibility, according to association CEO Daniel Durden. 
  • It simply opposes the most-recent revision process, which unfolded last year and could raise construction costs for multifamily buildings going forward, Durden said.
  • “We don't want to be seen as opposed to improving accessibility,” he said. “We don’t want to be the impediment to that. But we do want to make sure that it's done in a way that makes sense.”

How is it done now: Through the state’s Uniform Construction Code, which is enforced by the Pennsylvania Department of Labor & Industry. 
  • The state code is comprised of a mix of other codes developed primarily by the International Code Council, or ICC, a private nonprofit that sets industry standards.
  • The council revises the standards on a regular basis, and L&I basically incorporates the updates.
  • In 2008, however, state lawmakers created an advisory council and blessed it with the power to accept, reject or tweak the updates. 
  • The council includes representatives from labor and industry, as well as elected officials, all appointed by the governor and the legislature.

Then what’s the problem: The advisory council has no say over updates to the ICC’s accessibility standards, according to the builders’ lawsuit, which was filed in Commonwealth Court.
  • Thus, the lawsuit argues, the latest revisions represent an unconstitutional delegation of authority to an outside entity.
  • The latest revisions – published at the end of 2021 in the Pennsylvania Bulletin – also are more stringent than the existing requirements of the Americans with Disabilities Act and the Fair Housing Act, according to the lawsuit.

What are the revisions: They touch on features like the width of hallways and the spacing for wheelchair users to navigate kitchens, Durden said. Some are more technical in scope.
  • They apply generally to multifamily dwellings like townhome complexes, not to single-family homes, he added.
  • However, some changes could apply to other types of buildings, such as provisions covering water fountains and bathrooms.
  • For residential builders, Durden said, the changes will raise costs at a time when affordable housing is a government priority.
  • He did not have a cost estimate. But, he said, "We know it's going to be more. We know for some of the changes it's going to be a lot more," he said.
  • For other changes, the cost might not be that much, he acknowledged. But designers still will have to rethink their plans.
  • A spokesperson for L&I declined to comment, citing the pending litigation.

The legal line: The builders’ lawsuit frequently cites a recent case that sent shudders through the world of workers’ compensation.
  • In that case, known as Protz, the Pennsylvania Supreme Court sided in 2017 with people making arguments similar to the builders – that reliance on an outside entity to set state rules represented an unconstitutional delegation of authority.
  • The ruling in the Protz case led to new legislation.
  • Durden said the easiest fix in the builders’ case would be empowering the existing advisory council to review and, if needed, modify updates to accessibility standards.
  • “I think this is the path of least resistance,” he said.

Did you know that you can sponsor biznewsPA -- and reach more than 1,200 regional business leaders every weekday morning?

Quick takes

WHO'S MERGING: Barley Snyder. Effective Jan. 1, the Lancaster-based law firm absorbed Wyomissing-based law firm Leisawitz Heller, in what Barley Snyder described as its "biggest strategic transaction in more than 30 years." Terms of the deal were not disclosed but it adds 14 attorneys and 10 paralegals to the Barley Snyder staff, which now totals 123 attorneys at 11 offices in Pennsylvania and Maryland.
  • Barley Snyder already has an office in downtown Reading with 14 attorneys. It plans to keep that office, along with the former Leisawitz Heller office in Wyomissing, according to a press release.
  • "Joining forces with Barley Snyder enables our attorneys and staff to continue our reputation for excellent service, committed professionals, and an open and welcoming environment," Charles J. Phillips, former managing partner at Leisawitz and now a partner at Barley Snyder, said in a statement.

WHO'S HIRING: Penn State Health. The regional health system based in Dauphin County has named a chief nursing officer for the new hospital it is building in Lancaster County. Barbara Zuppa, a former executive with Reading-based Tower Health, is slated to start Jan. 17 as chief nursing officer for Penn State Health Lancaster Medical Center.
  • The 129-bed hospital is expected to open in late 2022 and employ nearly 900 people.
  • Zuppa (pictured below) was vice president of nursing operations for Tower Health.
  • She is at least the third Tower exec to jump to Penn State Health. Previous recruits include Claire Mooney, named COO of the Lancaster hospital, and Edward Chabalowski, hired as CFO for operations in Berks and Lancaster counties.

WHO'S BUZZING: West Shore Home.  The home-improvement contractor based in Cumberland County is opening its first office in Utah, aka the Beehive State. The Salt Lake City office has a general manager and is expected to start making sales within about two months, according to West Shore Home spokesperson Kirsten Page. 
  • West Shore Home is aiming to become a national name in the traditionally fragmented home improvement industry.
  • Founded in 2006, the company now has offices in 14 states. Utah is the 15th.


Got questions? Got feedback? Interested in supporting BizNewsPA?
Contact us at
Compiled and written by Joel Berg

Copyright © 2022 BizNewsPA, All rights reserved.

Want to change how you receive these emails?
You can update your preferences or unsubscribe from this list.

Email Marketing Powered by Mailchimp