Copy
View this email in your browser

Welcome!

Hello, and welcome to this latest edition of From a Climate Correspondent, a newsletter exploring the climate crisis around the globe.

Each week we share insights on the fight against climate change from our adoptive countries. This week we look at Paraguay and Brazil's mega-dam, which is up for renegotiation in a few years.

If you'd like to support us, you can invite us for a coffee over at our Patreon page. We're grateful for any contributions!

Thanks for reading and stay safe,
From a Climate Correspondent team - India, Jocelyn, Lou and Mat

No.22 by Jocelyn Timperley


The Itaipu Dam: how Paraguay is negotiating its energy future

The terms of the Brazil-Paraguay treaty setting out the terms of the Itaipu dam is up for renegotiation in 2023. Image credit: Guilherme Artoff/ Flickr

Paraguay, a landlocked country to the north of Argentina, has just 800 confirmed cases of coronavirus. It has been praised for its strong response, but also has low levels of testing and has led to many Paraguayans going hungry.


Meanwhile Brazil, its neighbour to the west, has become the hardest hit country in Latin America, with total cases accelerating to nearly 250,000. "Brazil is perhaps today the place with the fastest expansion of the coronavirus in the world, and that is a great threat to our country,” said Paraguay’s president Mario Abdo Benítez earlier this month.

Paraguay is one of the countries John Oliver likes to mislabel (“That’s actually Paraguay, not Uruguay”) in his jokes about how little we think about certain countries. Yet the inward flow of infection from Brazil is far from the country’s only international challenge along its Parana river border.

The joint treaty which led to the development of Itaipu, the enormous hydroelectric dam built by Paraguay and Brazil decades ago, is soon up for renegotiation. This offers the chance to Paraguay the prospect of more cash from its share of the electricity, and, some hope, the opportunity for a greener future for Paraguay.


Renegotiation
 

Itaipu is a fascinating example of a decades old energy decision that remains decidedly current. The joint treaty to build it to harness the world’s fast flowing falls was signed back in 1973, during the 35-year long dictatorship of Alfredo Stroessner. The dam began generating electricity in 1984.

It is still the world’s largest hydroelectric dam in terms of electricity production, with a record generation of 103,000 gigawatt hours in 2016. Some 35,000 people worked on its construction.

As one of the world's few binational dams, Itaipu’s 20 turbines are divided half and half on the Brazilian and Paraguayan sides.

“Because it's on a trans-boundary water source it's not just governed by the company's interests,” says Christine Folch, assistant professor of cultural anthropology at Duke University and author of Hydropolitics, a recent book on Itaipu. “It's also governed by political and international relations interests.”

Paraguay’s portion of the electricity of the dam is enough to power itself at least three times over. Under the terms of the current treaty, it exports most of its share to Brazil - at a rate well below the regional market rate. The treaty, however, set out a renegotiation process to be taken after 50 years - meaning an opening to change these conditions is coming up in 2023.

This has become a big deal in Paraguay. Fernando Lugo, the left-wing priest who served as president for four years from 2008, ran on a campaign promise to recover hydroelectric sovereignty.

“It was a financial tactic,” says Folch. “The idea was that by Paraguay recovering its sovereignty [...] it would wrest more resources from the dam. And those resources can then be applied to transforming the country socially.”

Lugo was deposed in an impeachment in 2012, restoring rule to the perpetually-in-power Colorado party (Strossner’s party, which stayed in power even after the dictatorship ended). However, the renegotiation remains a huge debate. The current president, Mario Abdo Benítez, last year faced the prospect of a possible impeachment after he signed a secret renegotiation agreement with Brazilian President Jair Bolsonaro on the dam - seen as unfavorable for Paraguay.

 

Clean energy surplus


Much of the debate around the renegotiation centres on how Paraguay could get a higher rate for the electricity it supplies to Brazil. But Folch argues there is something much more interesting available.

“What country on the planet has a massive surplus of carbon neutral green energy? That's already there, that doesn't have to be built?”

What if Paraguay instead launched an ambitious, out of the box, green revolution? says Folch. “A green industrialization, where you would know that the things that are being produced in the country are renewably sourced.”

Others are more sceptical. A friend of mine from Paraguay tells me people are unmindful on environmental issues, pointing out that in many places biomass and rubbish is still burned to get energy. “It takes more than a dam to make us green,” she says.

But Folch is not the only one excited about this possibility. In an interview with Folch last year Pedro Ferreira, former head of Paraguay’s public utility ANDE, outlined his “dream” of how Paraguay could both develop and become a zero emissions country even before Europe by electrifying its transport and industry.

“We could be an example of a small, middle income country that could have 100% clean energy,” he said. “We could have energy security for our young people, for all the generations that come after us. Paraguay can be an example of a country where, if we have sufficient help, we can achieve it.”

Must reads from the region

 

Argentina’s Failing Fracking Experiment, Nicholas Cunningham, Nacla
A film linking Chinese shoppers to Amazon deforestation sparked accusations that it was “insulting China” and unfairly appointing blame -- before being taken down.

Bolsonaro revives a plan to carve a road through one of Brazil’s last untouched areas, Fernanda Wenzel, Mongabay
President Jair Bolsonaro has revived a decades old plan to extend a highway through the largest protected tropical forest area in the world, writes Wenzel, a Brazilian journalist. The vast Calha Norte territory it would cut through is bigger than the United Kingdom and extremely biodiverse.

The Green Erasure of Indigenous Life, Christina Noriega, Nacla
The development of wind energy on Colombia’s Caribbean coast has provoked a discussion about how to safeguard Indigenous rights when they stand in the way of lucrative green businesses, writes Noriega, a Colombian-American journalist.

China continues to cut back Latin America loans, Robert Soutar, China Dialogue
New figures suggest a cooling of Chinese state-backed lending to Latin American governments to support energy and infrastructure projects- even before the coronavirus pandemic, writes Soutar. In their place, however, a range of new China-backed investment vehicles are emerging.

What else I've been listening to...


Latin America’s Outbreaks Now Rival Europe’s. But Its Options Are Worse. Anatoly Kurmanaev, Manuela Andreoni, Letícia Casado and Mitra Taj, New York Times

This extensive New York Times analysis highlights how a “devastating wave” of coronavirus has struck cities in Latin America even as the toll has eased in New York and European capitals. “Exhausted local officials in Ecuador, Peru and Brazil pointed to global test shortages and explained they were being outbid by richer nations on scarce medical supplies,” it reads.

Meanwhile, a fundraiser for the Paĩ Tavyterã indigenous communities in Paraguay outlines how they are also facing shortages of food and basic supplies. “While the Paraguayan state has promised aid, support is not reaching these communities. They need food and basic cleaning supplies to help them get through the crisis,” states the fundraiser, which is organised by researcher Jennifer Tucker and journalist William Costa.

Been forwarded this email?


Did someone send this on to you? Why not sign up yourself!

Who we are

Lou Del Bello is an energy and climate journalist based in Delhi, India.

Jocelyn Timperley is a freelance climate & science journalist based in San José, Costa Rica.

India Bourke is an environment journalist based in Hong Kong.

Mat Hope is investigative journalist based in Nairobi, Kenya.

Want to get in touch? Email us: reporter@climatecorrespondent.com

Follow us on Twitter!
Copyright © 2020 Climate Correspondent, All rights reserved.


Want to change how you receive these emails?
You can update your preferences or unsubscribe from this list.

Email Marketing Powered by Mailchimp